What the heck were they thinking?

Pitching prospect versus position prospect. What do you value more. Apparently GM Saffron likes pitching and GM elgman likes a solid everyday player. This was proved in the Tony Benavente for Zachrey Todd deal.

Charlotte obtained 3B Benavente who was the 31st overall pick in season 11. Tony had spent the last 3 seasons with the Woods big league club but started this season in AAA as Saffron decided to go with Gary Mabry this season. In his 246 games in the majors Tony hit .269 with 30 homers.

Cleveland picked up 21 year old starting pitcher Todd who was the 38th overall pick last season. Zachrey has a horrible rookie season going 2 and 12 with a 7.56 era. Todd was assigned to the Woods Low A ballclub.

Both clubs are very happy with the initial results of the trade as both players have picked up their game with the change of scenery. Benavente is hitting .348 after 72 games and Todd is 6 and 2 with a 2.59 era. Sometimes everybody wins. This may be a case in point.

What the heck were they thinking?

Pittsburgh and Kansas City completed a one for one trade of young Major League talent. The River Rats moved defensive SS Bruce Mercedes to the Golden Ox for Left handed starting pitcher Orber Guerrero. Mercedes a 1st round pick in season 12 had seen limited playing time in 2 seasons with Pittsburgh. Guerrero signed as an international free agent in season 11 at the age of 18 did not spend much time in the minors. Called up to the show at the ripe old age of 20 he has 5 full major league seasons of 30 plus starts. Despite an overall major league record of 42 and 83 going into this season Orber is generally considered the better player in the deal. Why then did Kansas City move him? One word: signability. Insiders say that Guerrero's agent has his heart set on testing the free agent market. Even thou Guerrero loved the Kansas City fans and was a strong role model within the Dominican community he has decided to listen to his agent. This is probably based on the 12 million signing bonus his agent got him back in season 11. The question is can GM grivfmd1 convince his agent to sign a multi year deal. It is this reporters view that if Pittsburg can resign Orber than they win the deal. If he chooses free agency than the slight edge swings back to Kansas City.

What the heck were they thinking?

First year GM scootermcray took one look at his ball club and decided it was a good time to rebuild. When first year GM yojames took his first look at his ballclub he decided "Win now Baby". Case in point the Pablo Maduro and Carl Thurman for Paul Hukata and Kenneth Simmons deal. Veterans for prospects plain and simple.

The Grasshoppers picked up 2 seasoned vets that were former 1st round draft picks back in season 7. Maduro a carear .298 hitter in 8 big league seasons is off to a good 1st half in season 18 hitting .304 with 11 dingers and 52 rbi's. Thurman a carear .280 hitter over parts of 11 big league seasons has never lived up to his potential. The former University of Richmond star was the 6th overall pick of the season 7 draft and decided to forego his senior year. Everyone expected him to be a 30 HR 30 SB guy. yojames is hoping the change of scenery in Syracuse will help ignite his carear. Since the trade Carl is hitting .257 with 8 longballs and 34 rbi's.

The Maize and Blue definately got younger. Hukata 23, from Japan, signed as an international free agent in season 13 receiving an 8 million dollar signing bonus. Milwaukee currently has Paul at AAA and the results have been promising. 10 saves, 2.50 era and 0.81 whip. Simmons 22, was the 12th pick overall in the season 16 draft after his sophmore year at Mid-state Technical College. Ken finished season 17 at AA with Syracuse but Milwaukee placed him with their High A ball club. Not happy with the demotion Ken got off to a slow start but things have gotten better and he currently has 12 saves, 3.76 era and 1.01 whip. He also has 43 k's in 40 innings.

Time will only tell who wins this deal but it seems both GM's got what they wanted.

Injury report for 1/25/11

So the draft is over and we have no reporter - such is life, guess you will have to figure out the winners and losers on your own. As to LOSERS here is the injury report.

Pittsburgs pitching took another blow as Rich Belhorn went on the 15 day DL, though he should be back before the all star break. Picking up 2 SPs in the previous week cushioned the blow. Mexico City also had a scare but Steve Scanlon(2B) should also be back shortly. The big news was Charlotte lossing a 3rd pitcher for the season as Leo Ramsey suffered a career shortening injury that puts him out for the season. Charlottes training budget of 16 and medical budget of 11 may be coming back to haunt the Associates. New Orleans lost reliever buddy Dykhoff for a month but he has not been a key cog in the Pelicans season. But has anyone?

Tough season in Charlotte - the question would now be, are they buyers? or sellers?

Next report at the All -Star break

Injury update #3 - as of 1/18

As noted in the last report the River Rats lost a major starting pitcher for the season - management continues to look for a replacement. How many other teams are in a similar situarion - if you are a "seller" it may be a good time to be in the market.

Over the last 8 days the "buying" owners could include (1) Milwaukee who lost RF Carlos Palmeiro for the season, Palmeiro was having an off year but.... (2) any of the clubs that lost major players in previous reports. Fortunately for most of the teams in Sandberg the rest of this weeks injuries were short term with the players due back shortly.

That is all until after the draft.

Injury update #2 1/10/11

In Sandberg the River Rats have their issues but injuries are not part of the problem (Within hours of posting this summary the River Rats were devastated by an injury to their already thin pitching corps. Hector Madura went down for the regular season with an arm injury. This will be a major test of the River Rats world class medical department (20M). Failure of the medical department to effectively treat Madura will be a long term blow to the River Rats). But other teams have been hit and hit hard. On 1/2/11 Durham of the Mexico franchise went done for 2 months but should return by the all-star break and be close to his old self. San Jaun was not so lucky. Hera is out for about the same amount of time but his shakey control will be even iffier on return. And Charlotte's Jesse Patrick took it even worse in his first outting - out for the season with a career threatening injury. Wes "too much hockey as a teen" Randolf also will be limitted on his return but at least it will be during the season and he will retain some limited value.
Things then calmed down for a few days until future stud Mark Schultz tour up his hamstrings. He will miss most of the season and effectively ended his SS career (as a 3B he may still flourish)(If Salt Lake does not have a solid medical team they need to evaluate getting one - this may not be his last injury). Hector Morales career may have ended with his season as Charlotte suffered its 2nd career threatening injury in a week (sharpen your trading skills fellows Charlotte may need to go shopping.).

Thats all until the prospects are available in the draft - then look for recap #3

Injury report #1 - post spring training

The NB thundercats took a blow in early spring training as Starting Pitcher Mack Scott went down with a rotator cuff injury. Las Vegas was hit with a major injury as well, CFer Dennis Diaz was felled by a sore shoulder and will miss the 1st month + of the season. Rolando Barajas of New Orleans has some elbow issues but should return early in the season. His absence should not have a major impact on New Orleans 1st week.

Whether NB or LV will be looking for replacements is not presently known.